Sunday, May 07, 2006

"Leak" of IPCC AR4

So, the nasty US Govt (in the form of the Climate Change Science Programme) has "leaked" the draft AR4 by putting it on a password-protected site, but issuing passwords automatically to anyone to bothers to ask for one. And the usual suspects are getting predictably outraged over it.

First, it does look like a clear breach of the conditions that the IPCC attached to the report - that it should not be distributed any further. That's naughty of the US CCSP. On the other hand, it is not clear that the IPCC has any real mechanism to refuse access to anyone who asks for it anyway - some septics have been observed to label themseves "IPCC expert reviewer" by way of credentials, and I've not heard of anyone complaining that they have been refused access - not that my lack of knowledge on these matters can be considered definitive of course, but does anyone have any evidence to the contrary?

But as importantly, those who are complaining in advance about the IPCC authors being flooded by "comment spam" have obviously not checked to see what the US CCSP has actually done. They are soliciting comments for themselves, which they will then take into account in their official comment, and they specifically instruct reviewers to not also email the IPCC directly. I assume the IPCC authors will not consider themselves to be under any obligation to deal with comments from people who they did not give the report out to in the first place. So the US CCSP will be the ones filtering any comment spam they generate. I can't imagine they will be silly enough to simply pass on the whole heap of comments unchecked (inclusive of any and all clue-free drivel they receive) as their official response, but it would be funny if they tried.

And furthermore, probably no-one had even heard of this "leak" until it was splashed in the press. I'm not going to blame the journalists really - information wants to be free - but there is some irony in people thundering about a "secrecy breach" and thereby magnifying it by orders of magnitude. Although I would agree that it is best to allow the review and redrafting to take place in an orderly manner and out of the full glare of the press, it's not as if there are any "secrets" in the document anyway - it is only a literature review, after all.

Golden Week Walk

"Golden Week" is a group of near-consecutive holidays when everyone in Japan goes on holiday together. We went up into the mountains around Kinpu-san in the Okuchichibu area on a 3 day trip to sleep shoulder-to-shoulder with 150 others in a small hut that would have comfortably held...oh, about 50 or so :-) I'm not exaggerating when I say that there was literally insufficient floor space for me to lie on my back on the first night. It's about the 4th time we've been walking in this area, but we've never hit peak season before.

This is Kobushigoya where we spent a rather sleepless night:


At this time of year there is still plenty of snow around above 2000m or so (at least, under the trees - open rocky areas were clearer), but we were lucky and had bright sunny weather for 3 solid days. And by staying in a more remote hut on the 2nd night, we even had room to lie down and sleep. Here is one of the views along the way:





And here is Jules enjoying a packed lunch of rice and a whole dried fish on the summit of Kinpu-san.

Tuesday, May 02, 2006

"Quake jolts area south of Tokyo"

Top News Article | Reuters.co.uk: "Quake jolts area south of Tokyo"

"Area south of Tokyo" happens to be where we live, in Kamakura. The house is still standing though. There have been several decent-sized quakes in the last couple of weeks, all centred on the Sagami Bay area just off the coast here. That was also the epicentre of the Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923...

Japanese abductees

A long-running story in the Japanese press has been the fate of the 13-16 people who were abducted from Japan to North Korea, apparently to teach Japanese to spies. It's been used repeatedly as a stick to beat the nasty North Koreans with (and of course it is a rather shocking story).

Recently, the USA's might has been enlisted to back up the Japanese outrage, complete with a congressional hearing and photo-op with Bush himself, at which he said:
"It is hard to believe that a country would foster abduction. It's hard for Americans to imagine that a leader of any country would encourage the abduction of a young child. It's a heartless country that would separate loved ones."
However, a quick google on Japan child abduction tells rather a different, but equally shocking, story. The links that come up first do not talk about the handful of Japanese abducted to North Korea...but instead, the much much larger number of children abducted TO Japan, following the breakdown of their parents' relationship. Yes, Japan is internationally renowned as a safe haven for child abduction - refusing to sign up to the Hague Convention on Child Abduction, and routinely ignoring and over-ruling any settlements made in a foreign court, irrespective of where the child has been raised. Even the USA itself condemns this behaviour in strong language:
in cases of international parental child abduction, foreign parents are greatly disadvantaged in Japanese courts, both in terms of obtaining the return of children to the United States, and in achieving any kind of enforceable visitation rights in Japan. The Department of State is not aware of any case in which a child taken from the United States by one parent has been ordered returned to the United States by Japanese courts, even when the left-behind parent has a United States custody decree.
The possibility of any mainstream Japanese media commenting on the obvious hypocrisy in this is vanishingly small, of course.

Sunday, April 30, 2006

Azaleas



Every week it seems that there's a different flower in full bloom round here. Currently it's the turn of the azaleas. This is the path down the main street in Kamakura (Wakamiya-oji), which was recently a tunnel of cherry blossom.

Hockey Stick Wars, round XXVII

Yawn. I'm not even going to provide a link. And if you don't know what I'm talking about, consider yourself lucky!

Saturday, April 22, 2006

Science on Hegerl et al (and Annan & Hargreaves)

Science has a review of Hegerl et al, which includes a brief nod to our work too, and a handful of other researchers endorsing the method and at least her results, if not explicitly ours :-)

While it all looks pretty encouraging, it is still some way from a clear confirmation of Gavin Schmidt's view that "Basically no one really believes that those really high sensitivities [measured in the past five years] are possible," and that even Hegerl et al's high estimate is unrealistic. Certainly I think Gavin is right - but as I said recently, I realise that our view is still somewhat of an outlier among people working in this sub-field. For example, not that long ago, Michael Schlesinger was actually claiming that climate sensitivity was "likely" (70%) greater than 4.5C, and he sounds unconvinced by Hegerl et al so far ("I'm not comfortable with the results."). It is possible that he had only had time to glance quickly over the paper before being asked for a quote - my experience is that it can take a few days for the full force of our arguments to sink in. Anyway, it remains to be seen whether, and how quickly, he modifies his views. I do sense some turning of the tide.